Summary
Sutton Middle School is a grades 6–8 school serving 313 students in Sutton, MA, a small town in central Massachusetts whose district, Sutton, ranks 143rd of 351 statewide, while the school itself placed 154th of 478 middle schools in 2025–2026 — the 68th percentile, with 3 stars.
That 3-star rating marks a rebound: after a long run of 4-star ratings through 2022–2023 that peaked at 116th of 501 (77th percentile), the school slipped to 171st and then 185th (62nd percentile) before climbing back to 154th this year. Test scores are a strength in most subjects. In 2025–2026, Sutton students outperformed the state in all four tested subjects: English language arts at 41.04% proficient (1 point above state), math at 47.52% (6.4 points above), science at 48.45% (7.5 points above), and civics at 56.70% — nearly 17 points above the statewide 39.77% and the best civics result among nearby middle schools, ahead of Grafton Middle at 55.37%. The clearest weak spot is 7th grade, where math proficiency is only 31.25% (more than 6 points below state) and ELA also falls short; 6th- and 8th-grade math are exceptionally strong, at 56.38% and 57.73%.
Compared with neighbors, Sutton Middle School trails Grafton Middle overall but beats Auburn Middle, Whitin Intermediate, Northbridge Middle, Oxford Middle, Charlton Middle, Sullivan Middle, Worcester East Middle, and Webster Middle School in most subjects, while Douglas Middle School is mixed — higher in ELA and math, lower in science and civics. Subgroup results are solid: male students rank in the 74th percentile, special education students 67th, and low-income students 66th, up from 41st two years earlier. With a student-teacher ratio of 13.9 and per-student spending of $15,282, Sutton produces stronger results than several nearby schools that spend more; free/reduced-lunch data was not available.
Thank you for your feedback!