Summary:
Colby has three schools serving PK through grade 12: Colby Elementary (PK–4), Colby Middle School (grades 5–8), and Colby Senior High (grades 9–12); together, they enroll 958 students. The schools’ average proficiency is 38% in ELA and 35% in mathematics, below state averages of 46% and 41%. Results differ considerably from school to school, and the clearest concern is Colby Middle School’s ELA performance: 26%, 20 percentage points below the average of the other two schools.
Colby Elementary stands out in the 2025–26 all-grade results, leading in ELA at 47% and mathematics at 43%; those results are 1 and 2 percentage points above the state, respectively. In ELA, Colby Senior High is next at 43%, while Middle is at 26%—a 20-point spread from Elementary to Middle. In mathematics, Middle scores 32% and High 31%; High is 10 points below the state. Middle leads High in science, 35% to 28%. Grade-level results add nuance: Elementary grade 4 ELA is 3 points above the state for that grade, while Middle’s ELA results are below the state in all four reported grades.
Recent movement is mixed. The schools’ average ELA result fell from 40% to 38% between 2024–25 and 2025–26, while the state result rose from 44% to 46%. Average mathematics rose from 33% to 35%, edging closer to the state. Elementary ELA increased by 6 percentage points, but High fell by 8 and Middle by 3; Middle mathematics improved by 8 points. SchoolDigger places Elementary at the 43rd percentile, High at the 46th, and Middle at the 20th. Attendance also varies: chronic absenteeism is 6% at Elementary, 14% at Middle, and 20% at High. Elementary has the highest student–teacher ratio, 15.3, and free/reduced-lunch rate, 39%, compared with ratios of 13.6 and rates of 35% at Middle and 30% at High; these are background differences, not explanations for test results.
Thank you for your feedback!