Summary
Spring Mill Elementary School is a K–5 school in Indianapolis, Indiana, serving 529 students as part of MSD Washington Township. It is a mid-performing school: ranked 526th of 1,015 Indiana elementary schools in 2025–26, placing it in the 48th percentile with 2 stars, just below its district's 57th percentile (3 stars). The school has improved noticeably over time, climbing from the 24th–25th percentile in 2020–22 to 48th in 2025–26, though it dipped to the 35th percentile in 2024–25 along the way. About 57.47% of students were eligible for free or reduced lunch in 2024–25, and per-student spending was $15,113 in 2023–24.
Math is Spring Mill's clearest strength. In 2025–26, 46.69% of students were proficient in math, above the district's 43.07%, while ELA (39.69%) and science (39.02%) came in slightly below district averages. Third-grade math was a standout at 57.78%, well above both district and state, and fourth-grade ELA also beat both. Fifth grade, however, is the weak spot: math was 32.94%, ELA 36.47%, and social studies 37.65% — all well below district and state levels. That split suggests early grades are producing gains that fade by the time students reach upper elementary.
Compared with nearby schools, Spring Mill holds its own against several similarly high-poverty schools. It outperforms Nora Elementary, Willow Lake Elementary, Greenbriar Elementary, Eastbrook Elementary, and College Park Elementary in math and science, and is roughly comparable to Fox Hill Elementary overall — even though Spring Mill serves more low-income students. Clearwater Elementary is the same-district benchmark, earning 4 stars and 85th percentile with lower poverty and lower absenteeism. Spring Mill trails far behind low-poverty, high-performing schools like Towne Meadow Elementary and Joseph J. Bingham School 84. One concern: chronic absenteeism was 20.0% in 2024–25, above the district (16.4%), the state (16.7%), and every nearby same-district school except Greenbriar — a likely drag on achievement.
Thank you for your feedback!