Summary
Cortland Elementary School is a small K–4 school serving 89 students in Seymour, Indiana, part of Seymour Community Schools, a district ranked 264th of 374 Indiana districts (29th percentile, 1 star). Despite that district context, Cortland has historically been a high performer: its SchoolDigger rank placed it 405th of 1,015 schools (60th percentile, 3 stars) in 2025–2026, down from 291st of 1,005 (71st percentile, 4 stars) the year before and a high of 90th of 1,027 (91st percentile, 5 stars) in 2017–2018.
Test scores are the clearest strength. In 2025–2026 ILEARN results, Cortland's English language arts proficiency was 47.5% versus 24.92% district-wide, math was 50% versus 28.13%, and science was 43.48% versus 27.03%. That ELA figure is the highest among its same-district peers, ahead of Emerson Elementary School (37.04%), and its math is second only to Emerson (59.26%). Among nearby schools, Southside Elementary School in Bartholomew County outperforms Cortland in all three subjects, while Scipio Elementary School has similar ELA, higher math, and lower science. Science results are volatile — 78.95% in 2024–2025 versus 43.48% in 2025–2026 — which is expected with such a small cohort.
Attendance is a standout: chronic absenteeism was 6.5% in 2024–2025, compared with 15.8% for the district and 16.7% statewide, and lower than every same-district peer, including Seymour-Jackson Elementary School (12.6%), Margaret R Brown Elementary School (75.95% free/reduced lunch), and Seymour-Redding Elementary School (15.3%). Cortland's free/reduced lunch rate is 39.33%, far below those peers, though it has risen from 34.06% in 2022–2023. Per-student spending reached $14,510 in 2023–2024, the highest among same-district schools, and the student–teacher ratio is 10.5, the lowest nearby, up from 15.5 in 2023–2024. Bottom line: strong ELA results, excellent attendance, and very small classes, with year-to-year variation worth watching.
Thank you for your feedback!