Summary
Crothersville Elementary School is a PK–5 school serving about 230 students in Crothersville, Indiana, part of Crothersville Community Schools, a district ranked 323 of 374 statewide.
The school ranked 767 of 1,015 in 2025–2026 — 24th percentile, 1 star — a steep decline from 2015–2016, when it was 421 of 1,046, or 60th percentile with 3 stars. In 2025–2026 ILEARN results, all-grade proficiency was 30.23% in ELA, 29.07% in math, and 13.64% in science. Those ELA and math figures are above the district's averages, but science is the clearest red flag: it is the lowest among all nearby comparison schools, where the next lowest is Margaret R Brown Elementary School at 23.47%, and many others fall in the 35–49% range. Fifth-grade social studies was 23.26% versus 47.2% statewide. Results split sharply by grade: third-grade math (61.9%) and ELA (42.86%) beat state averages, while fourth- and fifth-grade ELA, math, science, and social studies all fall far below state levels. ELA and math have improved recently, but not enough to lift the school out of the bottom quartile.
Attendance is a relative strength: chronic absenteeism was 14.8% in 2024–2025, better than the district's 22.1% and the state's 16.7%, though higher than Graham Creek Elementary School (10.7%) and Emerson Elementary School (11.1%). The free/reduced lunch rate of 46.52% is the lowest of any nearby school, and per-student spending was $10,763 with a student-teacher ratio of 15.8, up from 12.2 in 2022–2023. Compared with Austin Elementary School, about four miles away, Crothersville has higher ELA and math but far lower science. Graham Creek, with a similar enrollment size and higher poverty, scores dramatically higher — ELA 57.64%, math 69.44%, science 47.14% — showing that a similar-size nearby school with more low-income students is achieving far more.
Thank you for your feedback!