Summary
Bradie Shrum Elementary is a PK–5 school in Salem, Indiana, serving 748 students in Salem Community Schools, making it the largest elementary in its nearby comparison group. In 2025–2026, the school ranked 576th of 1,015 Indiana elementary schools (43rd percentile, 2 stars), while its district ranked 173rd of 374 districts (54th percentile, 3 stars). Current all-grade ILEARN proficiency is 31.98% in English Language Arts, 44.29% in math, 32.79% in science, and 52.46% in fifth-grade social studies.
Attendance and class size are relative bright spots. Chronic absenteeism is 11.8% in 2024–2025, down from 24.4% in 2020–2021 and below the district’s 16.9% and state’s 16.7%. The student-teacher ratio is 12.8, the lowest in the local comparison set. About 56.55% of students were eligible for free/reduced lunch, a mid-high local rate similar to West Washington Elementary’s 56.41%. Achievement is uneven: math is mid-pack locally, and fifth-grade social studies is above the state average at 52.46% versus 47.2%. ELA and science are weak. ELA is 31.98%, second-lowest nearby and above only Medora STEM Academy’s 17.5%; science is 32.79%, also second-lowest. Grade-level gaps include fourth-grade ELA at 26.23% versus the state’s 42.2%, fourth-grade science at 32.79% versus 43.8%, and fifth-grade math at 34.96% versus 42%.
The recent trend is concerning. The school peaked at 56th percentile and 3 stars in 2022–2023, then slipped to 49th, 45th, and 43rd percentile, returning to 2 stars in 2025–2026. Over that period, all-grade ELA fell from 38.96% to 31.98%, math slipped from roughly 47% to 44.29%, and fifth-grade social studies fell from 59.69% to 52.46%, though it remains above the state average. Comparable-poverty peers outperform Bradie Shrum: West Washington Elementary has a nearly identical free/reduced lunch rate but much higher ELA (67.43% versus 31.98%), math (75% versus 44.29%), and social studies (67.65% versus 52.46%). Brownstown Elementary, with similar poverty, also outperforms in ELA and science. Spending is $10,685 per student, in the middle of the nearby group, so spending alone does not appear to be the main constraint. The most actionable takeaways are to investigate the post-2022–2023 decline, target fourth-grade ELA and science and fifth-grade math, and learn from higher-performing local peers.
Thank you for your feedback!