Summary:
Mitchell, Indiana is home to four schools — two elementary, one junior high, and one high school — all operating within Mitchell Community Schools, together enrolling about 1,476 students from prekindergarten through 12th grade. The district is ranked 275th of 374 in Indiana, placing it in the 26th percentile with a 1-star rating. Grades are split across buildings: Hatfield Elementary School serves PK–2, Burris Elementary School serves 3–5, Mitchell Junior High School serves 6–8, and Mitchell High School serves 9–12.
Among schools with test data, Burris Elementary is the clearest bright spot: it outperforms the district in all-grade ILEARN ELA, math, and science, and posts the city's lowest chronic absenteeism at 6.6%. Hatfield Elementary has no state test scores, as expected for a PK–2 school, but it also shows strong attendance and the lowest free/reduced lunch rate. Mitchell High graduates 89.1% of students, essentially matching the state, and its Biology scores improved from 30.77% to 44.58% — yet SAT math sits at 9.57% against a state 25.6%. Mitchell Junior High is the weakest performer, falling below the district in ELA, math, and science in both available years, with the highest absenteeism in the city and 8th-grade math at just 10.38% versus a state 34.2%.
Attendance is notably stronger in the elementary grades than in the secondary grades, suggesting extra support may be needed as students move up. Mitchell Junior High has both the highest per-student spending and the lowest student-teacher ratio in the city, yet the weakest outcomes — money alone is not translating into results. Mitchell High and Burris Elementary both carry 2-star school ratings, while Mitchell Junior High has held 1 star for three straight years. Overall, the elementary schools look comparatively solid, and the district's low ranking appears driven largely by the middle school and the high school's math performance.
Thank you for your feedback!