Summary:
Seven elementary schools in ZIP code 62521 are all part of Decatur School District 61, with grade spans reaching from pre-K through grade 8; Muffley Elementary School, South Shores Elementary School, and Michael E Baum Elementary School serve K–6. The latest all-grades IAR results are for 2025–2026. The area’s results differ substantially from school to school, but the key overall finding is that every school with a reported result fell below the state proficiency rate in both ELA and math.
Montessori Academy for Peace leads the reported all-grades results: 42% in ELA and 19% in math, compared with state rates of 56% and 40%. Its ELA result was 27 points above the other six schools’ average, and its math result was 9 points above the other five schools reporting math. At the other end, Hope Academy had the lowest reported ELA result, 6%—15 points below the other schools’ average; its math result is suppressed. Dennis Lab School had the lowest reported math result, 5%, 7 points below the other reporting schools’ average. Michael E Baum Elementary School was second-highest in both subjects, at 23% ELA and 15% math.
Scores have improved modestly overall, though not always as quickly as the state benchmark: the ELA average rose from 17% in 2024–2025 to 18% in 2025–2026, while the state rate rose from 53% to 56%, widening the gap from 36 to 38 points. The six schools with reported math results rose from a 10% average to 11%; the state rate increased from 39% to 40%, and the average gap narrowed slightly, from 29.0 to 28.5 points. SchoolDigger ranks Montessori in the 22nd percentile with one star, while Johns Hill Magnet School is in the 3rd percentile with zero stars. As context, the free/reduced lunch eligible measure for 2024–2025 ranged from 53% at Montessori to 94% at Hope; the figures do not by themselves explain differences in results.
Thank you for your feedback!