Summary:
The 12 schools in Wheeling CCSD 21 include nine elementary schools and three middle schools. In 2025–2026, the schools averaged 49% in all-grades English language arts (ELA), compared with 56% statewide, and 38% in math, compared with 40% statewide. Results varied considerably by school: the range was 39 percentage points in ELA and 43 points in math. The most important finding is that those wide school-to-school differences make the district averages a poor guide to what families may find at an individual school.
J W Riley Elementary led in ELA at 69% and fifth-grade science at 76%, while Henry W Longfellow Elementary led in math at 63% and also scored 67% in fifth-grade science. Among middle schools, Cooper Middle led in ELA (66%), math (48%) and eighth-grade science (66%). At the lower end, Mark Twain Elementary had the lowest ELA and math results, at 30% and 20%; Oliver W Holmes Middle was lowest among middle schools in all three subjects, with 41% in ELA, 22% in math and 32% in eighth-grade science.
Results improved overall from 2024–2025: the school-average ELA score rose 11 points, and math rose 4 points. Every school improved in ELA; math improved at 10 schools, while Robert Frost Elementary and Mark Twain declined. SchoolDigger rankings also distinguish schools: Riley ranked in the 82nd percentile with four stars, Longfellow in the 74th with four stars, and Cooper in the 68th with three stars; Walt Whitman Elementary and Mark Twain ranked in the 8th and 9th percentiles. As context, all schools reported free/reduced lunch eligibility for school year 2024–2025; figures ranged from 25% at Longfellow to 80% at Whitman. That measure is an observation, not an explanation for school results.
Thank you for your feedback!