Summary:
The four schools in Shelbyville CUSD 4 serve students from kindergarten through grade 12: Shelbyville Kindergarten Center, Main Street Elementary School (grades 1–3), Moulton Elementary School (grades 4–8), and Shelbyville High School (grades 9–12). The clearest overall strength is English language arts (ELA), while mathematics results vary sharply by grade.
Moulton stands out in ELA: all five reported grades exceeded state proficiency, by 2 to 30 percentage points; grade 6 led with 89% proficient versus 59% statewide. Main Street also led the state in grade 3 ELA (65% versus 48%) and math (66% versus 49%), about 17 points higher in each. The clearest low result was Moulton grade 5 math: 24% proficient, 13 points below the state. At Shelbyville High School, grade 11 ACT ELA and math were 10 and 5 points above state results, while science was 3 points below. Its graduation rate was 99%, compared with 90% statewide. The Kindergarten Center has no listed test results.
Recent changes differ by school: from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, Main Street fell 8 points in ELA and 12 in math, though both remained above state levels. Moulton’s all-grades results rose 4 points in ELA and 3 in math. At the high school, ACT science fell 11 points year over year, shifting from above to below the state result. SchoolDigger’s reported percentile rankings also declined from 76 to 69 for Moulton and from 83 to 62 for the high school between 2023–2024 and 2025–2026. As context, all four schools reported free/reduced lunch eligible for SY 2024–2025: 58% at Main Street, 45% at Moulton, 38% at the high school, and 37% at the Kindergarten Center. Reported student–teacher ratios ranged from 11.8:1 at the Kindergarten Center to 14.4:1 at Main Street.
Thank you for your feedback!