Summary
Pomaikai Elementary School is a PK–5 school with 545 students at 4650 S Kamehameha Ave in Kahului, Hawaii, serving a comparatively affluent area within the Hawaii Department of Education, the state’s single statewide district where school-level statewide rankings matter most.
For most of the past decade, the school was a model of consistency: from 2015-2016 through 2024-2025 it earned nine straight 4-star years and ranked between the 70th and 80th percentile of Hawaii elementary schools, peaking at the 80th percentile (rank 41 of 204) in 2024-2025. The 2025-2026 results mark a step down: 3 stars, rank 65 of 203, 68th percentile — the first 3-star year recorded and the lowest percentile in ten years, though still above average. Achievement remains strong compared with nearby schools, but by a shrinking margin: 3rd of 11 in ELA (59% proficient), 4th in math (49%), and 3rd in science (61%). Math is the clearest concern, falling 11 points from 60% to 49%; the ELA–math gap widened to 10 points, the largest locally. Puu Kukui Elementary School has overtaken Pomaikai in ELA (67 vs. 59) and math (59 vs. 49) despite higher poverty and lower spending, while Kamalii Elementary School is close at 60% ELA and 56% math.
Other measures remain favorable: the free/reduced-lunch share of 25.87% is the lowest among the eleven comparison schools, chronic absenteeism is 21.0% (second-lowest), the student-teacher ratio is 14.7 (near the group median), and per-student spending is $15,889, slightly below the local average. The biggest warning signs are subgroup results: English Language Learner students fell from the 91st percentile in 2023-2024 to the 14th percentile in 2025-2026, and special education students dropped from the 84th to the 41st. Low-socioeconomic-status students recorded a 43rd-percentile result. Absenteeism ticked up from 20.0% to 21.0%, and the free/reduced-lunch share jumped from 17.18% to about 26% in recent years. Overall, the school remains high-performing and efficient, but the math slide, narrowed lead over peers with harder demographics, and sharp subgroup declines deserve close attention.
Thank you for your feedback!