Summary:
There are five elementary schools in zip code 33040 (Key West, FL), serving grades PK-8 and K-8 within the Monroe County School District, a 4-star district ranked 19th in Florida.
Sigsbee Charter School is the clear academic leader, earning a 4-star rating with the lowest chronic absenteeism (14.7%) and the lowest free/reduced lunch rate (19.21%). It significantly outperforms district and state averages in nearly every subject. In contrast, Horace O'Bryant School presents a paradox: it has the highest enrollment (1,011 students) and achieves near-perfect proficiency (98-100%) in advanced courses like Algebra 1 and Geometry, yet its overall state ranking is low (18th percentile) due to poor performance in standard grade-level tests. Poinciana Elementary School stands out for strong math performance, with 4th and 5th graders scoring 75% and 70% proficient, well above district and state averages, despite a high poverty rate (66.37%). Gerald Adams Elementary School has the highest poverty rate (74.63%) and consistently scores below averages. May Sands Montessori School is the smallest (90 students) but has the highest chronic absenteeism (36.9%) and limited test data.
Key takeaways for parents: socioeconomic status strongly correlates with performance, as Sigsbee (lowest poverty) excels while Gerald Adams (highest poverty) struggles. Higher per-student spending does not guarantee better results—Poinciana ($19,708) and Gerald Adams ($19,445) spend the most but are not top performers, while Sigsbee spends less ($16,555) and leads academically. Chronic absenteeism is a challenge across the area, averaging 22.1%, though better than the state average of 31.4%. Horace O'Bryant's advanced course success masks broader struggles, suggesting a "two-schools-in-one" dynamic. Poinciana's math strength offers a potential model for instructional excellence.
Thank you for your feedback!