Summary:
Summerland Key, Florida, is served by a single public school, Sugarloaf School, a combined elementary and middle school (PK-8) with 651 students that is part of the Monroe County school district.
Sugarloaf School presents a mixed picture of academic performance. The school is a standout in middle school mathematics, with 7th-grade math proficiency at 71% and Algebra 1 proficiency reaching an exceptional 95%, both far exceeding state averages. However, this strength is not uniform; 5th-grade science proficiency is a significant weakness at just 46%, well below the state average of 60%. The school also struggles with chronic absenteeism, which at 33.5% is dramatically higher than the district average of 21.8% and even exceeds the state average. This high absenteeism rate is a critical concern, as it likely undermines the school's overall academic progress despite a high per-student spending of $17,715.
Key metrics show a volatile state ranking, dropping from the 50th percentile (3 stars) in 2024-2025 to the 41st percentile (2 stars) in 2025-2026, even as some test scores improved. The school's performance is polarized: it achieves world-class results in advanced math but struggles in foundational science. The "middle school magic" seen in 6th and 7th grades does not carry over to 8th grade, where proficiency in both ELA and math drops sharply. For parents, this means Sugarloaf School offers exceptional opportunities for students strong in math, but families should be aware of the challenges in science and the significant issue of chronic absenteeism that affects the learning environment for all students.
Thank you for your feedback!