Summary:
Timnath, Colorado is served by three schools—Timnath Middle-High School, Bethke Elementary School, and Timnath Elementary School—all part of the highly rated Poudre School District R-1, offering education from preschool through 12th grade.
For parents, the standout is Bethke Elementary School, which ranks in the 95th percentile statewide (5 stars) and far outpaces the other local schools in every subject: 76% of its students are proficient in ELA and 70% in math, compared to 58.8% and 47.5% at Timnath Elementary School. Bethke also has remarkably low chronic absenteeism (11.5%) and very few students eligible for free/reduced lunch (8%). Timnath Middle-High School is a strong secondary option, ranked in the 86th percentile for high schools, with a 95.3% graduation rate and excellent SAT/PSAT reading and writing scores (78–88% proficient). Its math scores are weaker by comparison but still above state averages. Meanwhile, Timnath Elementary School is solidly above state averages but trails its elementary counterpart, especially in math (47.5% vs. 70.4%) and science (44% vs. 64.2%).
The most striking difference is between the two elementary schools, likely tied to the much higher share of students qualifying for free/reduced lunch at Timnath Elementary (30.8%) versus Bethke (8%). At the secondary level, Timnath Middle-High School shows a notable middle-school dip in math and science relative to its high school performance, with 7th and 8th grade math proficiency falling below district averages. That said, every Timnath school beats state averages in nearly all tested areas, and all three maintain lower chronic absenteeism than the district or state. If you're choosing between elementary schools, Bethke is the clear academic leader; for secondary, Timnath Middle-High offers strong literacy, graduation, and attendance outcomes, with math and middle-school growth as areas to watch.
Thank you for your feedback!