Summary:
This analysis examines two middle schools serving grades 6-8 in Stockton's 95212 zip code, with a combined enrollment of 1,258 students, revealing significant differences in performance and resources between a traditional district school and a charter school.
Aspire Benjamin Holt Middle, a charter school, stands out as the higher-performing institution, exceeding the state average in English Language Arts (54.2% proficient) and matching it in Math and Science, while operating within the Aspire Benjamin Holt Middle District. In contrast, Morada Middle, part of the Lodi Unified district, lags behind with proficiency rates notably below state averages across all subjects. Interestingly, Aspire achieves these stronger academic outcomes despite spending 26% less per student and having a significantly higher student-teacher ratio than Morada Middle.
Key factors for parents to consider include chronic absenteeism, which is lower at Aspire (17.1%) than at Morada (22.1%), and the consistency of performance, with Aspire maintaining a ranking in the top third of California middle schools for three consecutive years. While both schools serve communities with economic need, Aspire's model demonstrates notable efficiency and effectiveness in this area, particularly in English Language Arts where its students outperform the state average by a clear margin.
Thank you for your feedback!