Summary
San Mateo High serves 1,557 students in grades 9–12 in San Mateo, within the San Mateo Union High district. Its latest test results are above California’s averages in English language arts (ELA), math and science, but below the district in all three subjects. Among nearby comprehensive high schools, it ranks last in ELA and science. The most important finding for families comparing local options is that ELA is a particular relative weakness: the school trails every nearby comprehensive peer.
Math is San Mateo’s strongest subject relative to local schools, although it still falls short of comparison averages. In 2025–26, 48% of students were proficient in math, compared with 38% statewide and 51% districtwide; the four nearby comprehensive peers averaged 58%. ELA proficiency was 62%, above the state’s 49% but below the district’s 69% and the nearby peers’ 76% average. Science proficiency was 44%, versus 36% statewide, 51% districtwide and a 56% average among nearby peers. That leaves San Mateo below all four peers in science as well as ELA. In math, it ranked fourth of the five comprehensive schools, ahead of Hillsdale High. The peer group includes Mills High, Aragon High and Burlingame High; Peninsula High (Continuation) is a separate comparison.
Math has improved steadily: proficiency rose from 38% in 2022–23 to 48% in 2025–26, a 10-point gain. ELA rose 3 points over that span but has eased from its 2023–24 peak, while science fell 1 point overall and has been broadly flat. SchoolDigger rates San Mateo at the 83rd percentile with 4 stars; nearby Hillsdale is at the 85th percentile, while Mills, Aragon and Burlingame rank between the 94th and 97th percentiles with 5 stars. The student-teacher ratio is 19.5, close to the four peers’ 20.4 average. San Mateo reports 38% free/reduced lunch eligible in 2024–25, compared with a 19% average at those peers; this is context, not an explanation for test results. SchoolDigger’s statewide effectiveness ranking is notably lower for Hispanic Students, at the 35th percentile in 2025–26 versus 83rd overall, down from the 50th percentile in 2023–24. Its ranking for Special Education Students is at the 50th percentile, down from 74th in 2023–24.
Thank you for your feedback!