Summary
Located in Carmel, CA, Carmel Middle serves 468 students in grades 6–8. In 2025–2026, its proficiency rates were 18 points above California’s in English Language Arts (ELA), 20 points above in math, and 19 points above in science; however, they were 5, 5, and 3 points below the supplied all-grade rates for Carmel Unified, respectively. The key takeaway: Carmel’s results are strong compared with the state, but its district’s all-grade rates are higher in every subject.
Among nearby schools serving the same grades, Carmel was second in ELA, at 67%, behind Pacific Grove Middle at 73% and ahead of San Benancio Middle at 62% and Buena Vista Middle at 49%. Carmel led the group in math, with 59% proficient, compared with 57% at San Benancio, 57% at Pacific Grove, and 37% at Buena Vista. In science, Carmel’s 55% was second to Pacific Grove’s 62%, just ahead of San Benancio’s 54% and above Buena Vista’s 35%. So math is a standout locally, while ELA is Carmel’s least strong position among these peers.
Carmel’s results have generally declined since 2022–2023: ELA fell 6 percentage points, math 1 point, and science 5 points, while state rates rose in all three subjects. Carmel still outperforms the state, but its advantage narrowed most in science, by 11 points. SchoolDigger ranks Carmel 311th of 2,703 schools, in the 88th percentile with 4 stars; nearby Pacific Grove is at the 89th percentile. Carmel also had the lowest nearby student-teacher ratio, 13.1 compared with a nearby average of about 19.9. Its free/reduced lunch eligible measure was 17% in 2024–2025, among the lowest reported by nearby schools. SchoolDigger’s statewide measure of how well it serves Asian Students fell from the 99th percentile in 2018–2019 to the 76th in 2024–2025. For Special Education Students, the ranking dropped from the 92nd percentile in 2024–2025 to the 76th in 2025–2026, below Carmel’s overall 88th percentile.
Thank you for your feedback!