Summary:
The Newcastle Elementary district has two schools serving kindergarten through grade 8: Newcastle Charter (333 students) and Newcastle Elementary (164 students). In 2025–2026, both schools were above state proficiency in English language arts, math and science. The two-school averages were 75% in ELA, 64% in math and 71% in science, compared with state averages of 49%, 38% and 36%; the area’s strongest overall finding is that both schools exceed the state in all three subjects.
Newcastle Charter leads overall, with 78% proficiency in ELA, 66% in math and 74% in science; Newcastle Elementary scores 71%, 62% and 67%, respectively. That puts Charter ahead by 7 percentage points in ELA, 4 in math and 7 in science. SchoolDigger ranks Charter at the 90th percentile with 5 stars, versus the 81st percentile and 4 stars for Elementary. Still, Elementary has notable grade-level strengths: it leads Charter by 15 points in grade 7 ELA, ties in grade 8 ELA, and leads in math in grades 3, 5, 7 and 8, as well as grade 8 science. Charter’s math leads are especially large in grade 4 (17 points) and grade 6 (27 points).
Results improved at both schools in all three subjects from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, and the area’s average advantage over the state grew by 4 points in ELA, 4 in math and 7 in science. Charter’s gains were larger in each subject, especially math and science; SchoolDigger’s ranking rose 9 percentile points for Charter and 2 for Elementary over the same interval. The schools also differ in size and staffing: Charter has a 2024–2025 student–teacher ratio of 28.6, compared with 14.0 at Elementary. In 2024–2025, free/reduced lunch eligible students made up 18% at Charter and 13% at Elementary, a difference of 5 points; these figures are context, not an explanation for test results. Enrollment is relatively small, and the supplied data does not include tested-student counts or uncertainty estimates.
Thank you for your feedback!