School InsightsBeta · Arizona

Charter vs. traditional public schools, like for like

Charter schools often serve different students than the public school down the street, so comparing their rankings straight up misleads. Here each Arizona charter middle school is set only against traditional public schools serving a similar share of low-income students.

At first glance

Charter45th
Traditional36th

Typical school's statewide percentile. On raw rankings, the typical charter school ranks 9 points higher. But they serve different students, so that's not a fair fight.

Like for like

+16 points

Compared with traditional public schools serving similar students, charter schools rank 16 percentile points higher.

Side by side, among schools serving similar students

It depends on the neighborhood: charter schools trail where 20–39% of students are low-income (−7) and lead where 60–79% are (+26).

  • Typical charter school
  • Typical traditional public school
  • Middle half of traditional schools
  • Each charter school
Under 20%0 charter · 27 traditional
85th
No charter schools
20–39%3 charter · 40 traditional
55th48th
−7 charter
40–59%3 charter · 66 traditional
21st45th
+24 charter
60–79%4 charter · 23 traditional
6th32nd
+26 charter
80% or more0 charter · 1 traditional
No charter schools

Statewide percentile in the 2025-26 rankings, all students. Point at a dot to see the school; click it to keep its card open.

Not shown: magnet schools (no ranked school is marked magnet in the federal school data); virtual schools (8 ranked, too few to compare). A fair comparison needs at least 10 middle schools of a type with a low-income figure.

Charter schools that do best for the students they serve

Ranked by how far each school sits above the typical traditional public school serving a similar share of low-income students.

SchoolLow-incomeStatewidevs. similar traditional
Vista College Prep Sueno ParkPhoenix 64% 46th +40
Vista College Preparatory - Metro North MiddlePhoenix 61% 44th +38
Acorn Montessori Charter SchoolPrescott Valley 46% 49th +28
Pensar AcademyPhoenix 54% 45th +24
Imagine Cortez Park MiddlePhoenix 69% 19th +13
Imagine East Mesa MiddleMesa 37% 62nd +7
Academy of Tucson Middle SchoolTucson 49% 26th +5
Imagine Desert West MiddlePhoenix 63% 4th −2
Imagine Surprise MiddleSurprise 26% 48th −7
Center for Academic Success #4 - Douglas 5-8Douglas 33% 40th −15
Every charter school, in numbers (10)
SchoolLow-incomeStatewidevs. similar traditional
Vista College Prep Sueno ParkPhoenix 64% 46th +40
Vista College Preparatory - Metro North MiddlePhoenix 61% 44th +38
Acorn Montessori Charter SchoolPrescott Valley 46% 49th +28
Pensar AcademyPhoenix 54% 45th +24
Imagine Cortez Park MiddlePhoenix 69% 19th +13
Imagine East Mesa MiddleMesa 37% 62nd +7
Academy of Tucson Middle SchoolTucson 49% 26th +5
Imagine Desert West MiddlePhoenix 63% 4th −2
Imagine Surprise MiddleSurprise 26% 48th −7
Center for Academic Success #4 - Douglas 5-8Douglas 33% 40th −15

How this works

Why not just compare rankings?
Test scores track family income closely. If one kind of school serves more low-income students, it will rank lower even if it teaches just as well. So schools are first sorted into five groups by their share of low-income students (free or reduced-price lunch), and each charter school is compared only with traditional public schools in its own group.
Reading a row
The purple dot is the typical (median) charter school in that group, the gray dot the typical traditional public school; the number on the right is the gap between them in statewide percentile points. The gray bar shows where the middle half of traditional schools rank, so you can see how much schools vary.
The like-for-like number
The row gaps, averaged and weighted by how many charter schools each group holds. Groups with fewer than 3charter schools or 5 traditional schools are left out of it. It describes typical schools, not any one school; the dots show how widely charter schools differ from each other.
What's left out
Private schools, schools without a low-income figure, and schools too new or too small to rank. Rankings come from state test scores, one measure of a school. Read how SchoolDigger ranks schools.

Diagnostics