Summary:
Zip code 35210 is home to two middle schools serving grades 6 through 8: Irondale Middle School and WE Putnam Middle SchoolMagnet, which together offer families a stark contrast in academic performance, resources, and student outcomes within the same community.
Irondale Middle School is the clear standout in this area. It ranks in the 16th percentile statewide (371 out of 443), compared to WE Putnam Middle SchoolMagnet’s 5th percentile (423 out of 443). Irondale outperforms its neighbor in every subject and grade level—for example, 6th-grade math proficiency is 8.47% versus just 1.47% at WE Putnam, and 8th-grade science proficiency is 31.37% versus 11.11%. Irondale also has a much healthier chronic absenteeism rate of 10.7%, which is below the state average of 12.0%, while WE Putnam struggles with a 27.1% rate. Irondale is part of the Jefferson County district, and its absenteeism is also better than that district’s 16.9% average.
Despite its “Magnet” label, WE Putnam Middle SchoolMagnet faces significant challenges. It spends considerably more per student ($13,151 versus $9,209 at Irondale) and has a lower student-teacher ratio (10.8 versus 15.9), yet its test scores are critically low—including 0% proficiency for 8th-grade math in the 2024-2025 school year. The school also has a higher percentage of students on free/reduced lunch (84.24% versus 74.65%). Interestingly, the English proficiency gap between the two schools is much narrower than in math, and WE Putnam showed some improvement in 8th-grade science and English from 2024-2025 to 2025-2026. For parents, the data clearly points to Irondale Middle School as the stronger academic choice, while WE Putnam Middle SchoolMagnet may warrant a closer look at its programs and support services before enrolling.
Thank you for your feedback!