Summary:
Zip code 25206, located in the rural community of Comfort, West Virginia, is home to just one elementary school, Sherman Elementary School, which serves students from Pre-Kindergarten through 5th grade with a total enrollment of 234 students.
Sherman Elementary School is a remarkable standout, ranking 25th out of 355 elementary schools in West Virginia (93rd percentile, 5-star rating) for the 2025-2026 school year, and it ranked 11th in the state for the two prior years. This is especially notable because the school belongs to Boone County Schools, a district that ranks in the bottom 20% of West Virginia districts (44th out of 54). Academically, Sherman dramatically outperforms both its district and the state: math proficiency is 65.7% (vs. 31.2% district and 39.4% state), English Language Arts proficiency is 76.2% (vs. 43.6% district and 47.6% state), and 5th-grade science proficiency is 52% (vs. 32.3% district and 34.6% state). The school's 5th-grade ELA proficiency rate of 88% is nearly double the state average, and its favorable 11.1:1 student-teacher ratio supports individualized attention in a small-school environment.
For parents, the key takeaway is that Sherman Elementary is an exceptional school that achieves top-quartile results despite its district's struggles, making it a model of instructional efficiency. While math proficiency dips notably between 3rd grade (76.5%) and 4th grade (58.1%), all grade levels still exceed state averages. Science is a relative weakness compared to math and ELA, but it remains above state norms. With consistent 5-star performance over three consecutive years and per-student spending of $13,022, this school delivers outstanding outcomes without exceptional funding, making it an excellent choice for families in the area.
Thank you for your feedback!