Summary:
The city of Seth, West Virginia, is served by two schools within the Boone County Schools district: Sherman High School (grades 9-12) and Sherman Junior High School (grades 6-8), together enrolling about 529 students in this rural Coal River Road community. There is no elementary school within city limits, so younger students commute to nearby towns.
The standout is Sherman Junior High School, which has surged to 31st out of 161 middle schools statewide (81st percentile) and earned a 4-star rating—the only school in Seth above 1 star. Its students dramatically outperform both district and state averages in English Language Arts (66.3% proficient vs. 47.6% statewide) and math (46.0% vs. 39.4% statewide). However, a troubling pattern emerges within the junior high: proficiency falls sharply as grade level rises, with 6th-grade math at 65.5% plummeting to just 23.2% by 8th grade. In contrast, Sherman High School ranks in the 12th percentile (92nd of 105 schools) with a 1-star rating. Its 11th-grade math proficiency is critically low at 10.7% (half the state average), though it does exceed the district's 7.9% rate. The high school's graduation rate is solid at 92.0%, and it spends $2,129 more per student ($11,329 vs. $9,200) than the junior high, yet performs far worse academically.
The most urgent takeaway is the "middle school cliff": strong 6th-grade gains are lost by 8th grade, feeding underprepared students into an already struggling high school. Science proficiency at the junior high also dropped 7.4 points year-over-year (30.6% to 23.2%). While Sherman High School showed a dramatic math improvement (4.8% to 10.7%), its ELA and science scores declined. For parents, this means the junior high offers excellent early-middle-school instruction, but the steep grade-level decline—especially in math—should be a red flag. The district's 1-star rating and 44th-place finish out of 54 districts suggest systemic challenges, but the junior high's success proves improvement is possible. Addressing the 6th-to-8th-grade slide is the clearest path to breaking the cycle of low high school performance.
Thank you for your feedback!