Summary:
Comfort, West Virginia, is home to a single school, Sherman Elementary School, which serves students in grades PK through 5 and is part of the Boone County Schools district.
For parents in this small rural community, Sherman Elementary is a true standout. Despite its district ranking in the bottom 20% statewide (44th out of 54 districts), this school has earned a 5-star rating for three consecutive years and currently ranks 11th out of 355 elementary schools in West Virginia—placing it in the top 3% of the state. The school's academic performance is exceptional across the board. In the most recent testing year, 76.2% of students were proficient in English Language Arts, compared to the state average of 47.6%, and 65.7% were proficient in math, versus the state average of 39.4%. The strongest results come from 5th grade ELA, where an impressive 88% of students met proficiency standards—37 points above the state average. Even the school's weakest subject, science, outperforms the state by more than 17 points.
With a favorable student-to-teacher ratio of 11.1:1 and per-student spending of $13,022, Sherman Elementary achieves these top-tier results without excessive financial resources, suggesting highly effective teaching and resource allocation. While math scores dip somewhat in 4th grade (58.1% proficiency) compared to 3rd grade (76.5%), every grade level still significantly exceeds state averages. This consistent, year-over-year excellence—ranked 25th, then 11th, then 11th—demonstrates that this is no one-year fluke. For families in Comfort, Sherman Elementary proves that a small rural school can deliver an education that rivals the very best schools in West Virginia, making it an excellent choice for elementary-aged children.
Thank you for your feedback!