Summary:
ZIP code 54151 is home to a single elementary school, Niagara Elementary, serving grades PK–6 with 271 students as part of the Niagara School District in a small Wisconsin community where nearly half of students (46.86%) qualify for free or reduced lunch.
Niagara Elementary earned 3 stars and ranked in the 55th percentile among Wisconsin schools in 2025–2026, above the state median and ahead of its district's overall 43rd-percentile, 2-star rating. Its standout strength is attendance: chronic absenteeism was just 7.3%, well below the district's 9.0% and far under the state's 17.3%. Fourth grade is the academic bright spot, exceeding state proficiency in every subject tested in 2025–2026 — Social Studies at 83.87%, Science at 70.97%, ELA at 77.42%, and Math at 67.74% — all roughly 15 to 24 points above state averages. Fifth and sixth grade ELA also improved year over year, with grade 5 rising from 41.18% to 57.58% and grade 6 from 32.43% to 44.12%.
The main concern is math, which declined in every tested grade from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026. The school's simple math average fell from 61.80% (8.17 points above state) to 50.75% (2.51 points below state). Sixth grade math is the weakest result, at 29.41% proficient — 24.19 points below the state and down from 37.84% the prior year. Fourth grade math and ELA also slipped from exceptionally high levels, though both remain well above state. With per-student spending of $13,551 and a 14:1 student-teacher ratio, families can expect small classes and strong attendance and 4th grade outcomes, but should watch the math trend closely, especially in the upper grades.
Thank you for your feedback!