Summary:
ZIP code 53158 in Pleasant Prairie, Wisconsin is home to three public elementary schools — Pleasant Prairie Elementary, Whittier Elementary, and Prairie Lane Elementary — all serving grades PK–5, all operating within Kenosha School District, and together enrolling 1,452 students. That shared district context matters: Kenosha School District itself ranks 340th of 432 Wisconsin districts (21st percentile, 1 star). Yet the three schools inside it perform very differently from one another, which makes this a useful set for families to compare.
Prairie Lane is the clear standout, ranked 117th of 1,039 elementary schools statewide (89th percentile, 4 stars) in 2025-26, after 94th (91st percentile, 5 stars) and 65th (94th percentile, 5 stars) in the two prior years. Its average proficiency across the six tested ELA and Math grades was 73.9% in 2025-26, against a 53.2% state average. Whittier is the opposite story: its state rank has fallen three years running (379th to 584th to 660th), and its Science proficiency of 35.82% sits 17.6 points below the state. Pleasant Prairie holds the middle with steady 3-star ratings, though it beat the state on only 4 of 8 tests in 2025-26 after beating all 8 the year before.
A few patterns stand out. All three schools beat their own district's average in nearly every subject, so students here are generally doing better than the district they belong to. Resources don't explain the gaps: student-teacher ratios span just 13.9 to 14.6 and per-pupil spending $12,740 to $13,681, yet Whittier's and Prairie Lane's ELA/Math composites differ by 22.7 points. Whittier actually has the lowest chronic absenteeism (9.4%) but the lowest scores. Science is a soft spot for two of the three schools, and all three lost state-rank ground last year.
Thank you for your feedback!