Summary
Butler Middle is a grades 6–8 school serving 786 students in the Waukesha School District in Waukesha, WI, making it larger than its two same-district middle-school peers. For 2025–2026 it ranked 285th of 643 Wisconsin middle schools — the 56th percentile with 3 stars — almost identical to the district's own 57th-percentile, 3-star rating. Its rank history is steady rather than rising: mostly 3 stars across the past decade, with occasional 2-star years and no sustained move into the top third of state middle schools.
On the 2025–2026 Forward Exam, Butler scored above the state average in every tested subject and grade except 8th-grade science, where 48.32% were proficient, below both the district's 54.66% and the state's 51.86%. It trailed the district in every subject except 8th-grade social studies, a relative strength at 67.65%. Eighth-grade math has climbed sharply, from 21.34% proficient in 2022–2023 to 62.18%, now nearly matching the district and well above the state. Within the district, Butler outperforms Horning Middle in every tested subject, but trails Les Paul Middle in every one — for example, 7th-grade math at 56.52% versus Les Paul's 74.66%. Nearby suburban schools such as Merton Intermediate and Pilgrim Park Middle rank in the top few percent statewide.
Attendance is improving: chronic absenteeism fell to 16.1% in 2024–2025, better than the state but worse than the district, and better than Horning's 22.4% while trailing Les Paul's 13.1%. The school's overall ranking masks uneven results across student groups. Comparative results are stronger for female students (66th percentile, 3 stars) and weaker for male students (46th, 2 stars), English learners (21st, down from 34th three years ago), students with disabilities (48th, down from 71st), and low-income students, who have sat near the 33rd percentile for three straight years. Butler spends $13,885 per student with a 14.1 student-teacher ratio — less than Horning and Les Paul, though in line with several higher-performing nearby districts.
Thank you for your feedback!