Summary
Whitehorse Middle is a grades 6–8 school at 218 Schenk St in Madison, WI, serving 415 students as part of the Madison Metropolitan School District. In 2025–2026, it ranked 529th of 643 Wisconsin middle schools (18th percentile, 1 star), and the district ranked 321st of 432 districts (26th percentile, 1 star). It has stayed in the bottom fifth for a decade, always 1 star. Its average 2025–2026 proficiency is about 36.2%, versus roughly 50.1% for the district and 55.5% for Wisconsin. It performs similarly to Badger Rock Middle, James Wright Middle, Sherman Middle, and Sennett Middle, above Black Hawk Middle and One City Preparatory Academy, but far below O'Keeffe Middle—1.76 miles away in the same district—as well as Indian Mound Middle and Glacial Drumlin School.
The school has been below district and state in every reported subject and grade in all four provided years. The weakest area is 6th grade: in 2025–2026, math was 21.74% and ELA 28.47%, both down from 2024–2025. Upper grades show gains: Math 7 rose from 20.9% in 2022–2023 to 43.17%, Math 8 from 15.72% to 38.46%, and Social Studies 8 from 39.52% to 48.72%. Science remains low at 31.62%. Chronic absenteeism was 32.4% in 2024–2025, above the district’s 29.6% and Wisconsin’s 17.3%, though down from 48.6%. Dropout was 0.3%. The free/reduced lunch rate was 59.04%, per-student spending was $18,641, and the student-teacher ratio of 12.6 was the highest among nearby comparison schools.
For parents, the key takeaways are persistent low overall performance, some upper-grade gains, and a clear strength in serving English Language Learner students, whose effectiveness ranking was 91st percentile with 5 stars in 2025–2026. Low-SES students ranked 6th percentile with 0 stars, while 6th-grade math/ELA and high chronic absenteeism are concerns. Resources look mixed: the school spends less per student than most Madison Metropolitan School District peers and has a higher student-teacher ratio, yet Glacial Drumlin School spends less but performs much higher. The contrast with O'Keeffe Middle and nearby higher-performing districts such as McFarland School District and Monona Grove School District shows how much variation exists in the area.
Thank you for your feedback!