Summary:
The Madison Metropolitan School District in Wisconsin includes 12 middle schools serving grades 6–8, together enrolling 4,990 students across the city of Madison, from the 92-student Badger Rock Middle to the 790-student Hamilton Middle. The district as a whole ranks 321 of 432 districts in the state (26th percentile, 1 star), but that single number hides enormous differences between its schools.
At the top, Hamilton Middle ranks 21 of 643 schools (97th percentile, 5 stars) with an average proficiency of 80.6% across the eight reported 2025–2026 tests, the lowest chronic absenteeism in the group (16.9%) and the highest single test score in the data set (89.54% in 8th-grade Social Studies). Spring Harbor Middle follows at the 89th percentile (4 stars, 73.6% proficiency), and O'Keeffe Middle is above both district and state averages (65th percentile, 60.0%). Toki Middle sits near the middle (49th percentile, 54.5%). At the other end, Black Hawk Middle ranks 562 of 643 (13th percentile, 1 star) with 28.6% proficiency and 41.9% chronic absenteeism — the most extreme outlier in the data.
Only three schools (Hamilton, Spring Harbor, O'Keeffe) exceed the state average of about 55.5%, and only four top the district average of about 50.1%. Free/reduced lunch rates track closely and inversely with proficiency, ranging from 19.37% at Hamilton to 70.33% at Black Hawk, with a correlation near −0.96. Math is the weakest subject almost everywhere, while Social Studies is usually strongest. Chronic absenteeism is a district-wide issue: the district rate is 29.6% against the state's 17.3%, and only Hamilton falls below the state figure. Notably, spending and class size do not predict results here — Hamilton has the lowest per-student spending ($16,988) and highest student-teacher ratio (14.4), while Black Hawk has the lowest ratio (8.7) yet the weakest outcomes. Dropout rates are near zero everywhere (0.0%–0.7%), and improvement trends are mixed, with Sherman, James Wright and Sennett gaining ground but still ranking in the bottom quartile.
Thank you for your feedback!