Summary:
Zip code 23233 contains Quioccasin Middle, Pocahontas Middle, Nuckols Farm Elementary, Gayton Elementary, Short Pump Elementary, Pinchbeck Elementary, Ruby F. Carver Elementary, and Pemberton Elementary — eight schools serving roughly 5,135 students across six elementary schools (PK–5) and two middle schools (6–8), with no high schools in the immediate area. All schools belong to Henrico County Public Schools, a district ranked in the 31st percentile statewide, yet this zip code contains some of its very best schools and some of its most challenged ones.
This is a neighborhood of two very different educational worlds. The low-poverty, high-performing cluster includes Nuckols Farm Elementary (92nd percentile, 5 stars), Gayton Elementary (92nd percentile, 5 stars), Pemberton Elementary (93rd percentile, 5 stars), Short Pump Elementary (79th percentile, 4 stars), and Pocahontas Middle (81st percentile, 4 stars). At the other extreme, Quioccasin Middle (10th percentile) and Ruby F. Carver Elementary (21st percentile) struggle with grade-level SOL proficiency in the 20–28% range for math and chronic absenteeism above 12%. Pinchbeck Elementary is the standout exception: despite a 90% free/reduced lunch rate, it ranks in the 59th percentile and posts 5th grade reading scores above the state average.
Several patterns matter for parents. Chronic absenteeism tracks performance closely — the top schools all stay below 6% while the lowest-performing schools exceed 12%. Spending does not guarantee success: Gayton Elementary spends the least ($9,336 per student) yet ranks among the best, while Ruby F. Carver Elementary spends more ($11,008) with far weaker results. At the middle school level, advanced course proficiency at Quioccasin Middle exceeds 90%, but this masks grade-level math scores near 20–28%, showing that a small, selected group of students drives those advanced results. Parents should evaluate each school individually rather than assuming the whole zip code performs the same, since the gap between the top and bottom schools here is enormous.
Thank you for your feedback!