Summary:
Zip code 22312 in Alexandria, Virginia is home to two middle schools—Glasgow Middle and Holmes Middle—both serving grades 6 through 8 as part of Fairfax County Public Schools, a highly ranked Virginia district. Together these schools serve roughly 2,583 students, with about 81% eligible for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating a high-poverty student population.
Holmes Middle is the stronger overall performer, ranking 347th out of 416 Virginia middle schools compared to Glasgow Middle's 371st. Holmes posts better reading proficiency (61.1% vs. 57.5%), better 8th-grade science (57.8% vs. 51.4%), a lower poverty rate (72% vs. 85.8%), more per-student spending ($14,180 vs. $12,567), and smaller class sizes (10.9 vs. 13.8 student-teacher ratio). Glasgow counters with stronger grade-level math proficiency (22.4% vs. 14.8%), better attendance (12.8% chronic absenteeism vs. 17.9% at Holmes), and an earlier advanced math pathway—Glasgow offers 6th-grade Algebra I while Holmes does not.
Both schools share a troubling pattern: near-perfect proficiency in advanced math (Algebra I and Geometry) but alarmingly low proficiency in grade-level math. This is most extreme at Holmes, where 7th-grade math proficiency collapsed to just 2.5%. Despite being in a high-performing district, both schools sit in the bottom 20% of Virginia middle schools, with proficiency gaps of up to 40 percentage points behind district averages in some subjects. Holmes shows that more spending and smaller classes don't automatically solve academic gaps, while Glasgow shows that higher poverty doesn't preclude better attendance. The good news: both schools improved their state rankings over the past two years, with Glasgow rising from 0 stars to 1 star.
Thank you for your feedback!