Summary
Chincoteague High is a small combined middle/high school in Chincoteague, Virginia, serving 271 students in grades 6–12 as part of Accomack County Public Schools. Despite a student population where more than 96% qualify for free or reduced lunch, the school earned a 4-star rating and ranked 88th out of 331 Virginia high schools (73rd percentile) in the 2025–2026 cycle, following a 5-star, 95th-percentile finish in 2023–2024. The district overall carries a 2-star rating, making this school a clear standout.
Academically, Chincoteague High shines brightest in math, science, and writing. In 2025–2026, 92.9% of 9th-grade Algebra I students passed their SOL test (80.2% statewide), and 96.7% of Biology students passed (68.9% statewide). The 11th-grade Writing SOL pass rate has consistently exceeded the state average, reaching 85.1% in 2025–2026. The school also posts a 97.1% graduation rate, well above the state (92.3%) and district (88.8%) averages. Notably, its low-income students ranked #2 in Virginia in 2024–2025 — a remarkable achievement for a school where nearly every student is economically disadvantaged. By comparison, nearby Arcadia High earned just 2 stars and placed in the 34th percentile, with an 88.2% graduation rate.
Chincoteague High also benefits from more resources than its counterpart, spending about $11,080 per student versus $8,083 at Arcadia High, and maintaining an 8.4-to-1 student-teacher ratio compared to 11.8-to-1. However, chronic absenteeism ran at 17.2% in 2024–2025, above the state average of 14.8% and well above Arcadia's 6.6%. Middle-grade reading and civics scores also lag, with 7th-grade English Reading at 60% proficiency versus 73% statewide. And because the school is small, year-to-year rankings can swing noticeably. Still, the overall picture is positive: this school delivers strong results for its students despite significant socioeconomic challenges.
Thank you for your feedback!