Summary:
This analysis examines 12 elementary schools in zip code 78501, serving grades PK-5 in parts of McAllen and Edinburg, Texas, within districts including McAllen Independent School District (Isd), Idea Public Schools, Sharyland Independent School District (Isd), Edinburg Consolidated Independent School District, and Horizon Montessori Public Schools.
The standout school in the area is Thigpen-Zavala Elementary, which ranks in the 87th percentile statewide despite having the highest poverty rate (96.6% free/reduced lunch), demonstrating exceptional academic performance that far exceeds state averages in Reading, Math, and Science. In contrast, Wilson Elementary is the lowest-ranked school at the 13th percentile, with only 20.31% of 5th graders proficient in Math compared to 46.24% statewide, indicating a need for significant intervention. Milam Elementary is the largest school (811 students) with the lowest poverty rate (53.39%) and ranks in the 84th percentile, serving as a benchmark for consistent, efficient performance. Charter schools show mixed results: Idea McAllen Academy underperforms at the 36th percentile, while Horizon Montessori - Stem Academy ranks at the 56th percentile with strong 5th-grade Reading scores (78.57% proficient) but weak Math scores.
Key metrics reveal an average free/reduced lunch rate of about 84%, with spending per student ranging from $7,983 at Idea McAllen Academy to $13,224 at Alvarez Elementary. Notably, higher spending does not guarantee success—Alvarez spends the most but ranks in the 33rd percentile, while Milam spends less ($10,040) and ranks in the 84th percentile. The McAllen ISD district shows a paradox of extremes, containing both the top and bottom performers, suggesting individual school leadership matters greatly. Additionally, students taking the STAAR test in Spanish often outperform the state average for Spanish test-takers but still lag behind English-proficient peers, indicating effective bilingual programs that have not yet closed the achievement gap.
Thank you for your feedback!