Summary:
This analysis examines six middle schools in the 77099 zip code of Houston, Texas, serving grades 5 through 8 across three districts: Alief Independent School District (Isd), KIPP Texas Public Schools, and Harmony Public Schools - Houston South, all serving a community with high economic disadvantage.
The standout high-performers are the two charter schools. Harmony School Of Innovation - Houston ranks in the 81st percentile statewide with a 4-star rating, excelling in advanced math with a 98.21% proficiency rate in Algebra I. KIPP Academy Middle ranks in the 78th percentile with a 4-star rating, achieving a 78.51% proficiency rate in 8th-grade Reading and a 0.0% dropout rate. In contrast, the four Alief ISD schools struggle significantly. Olle Middle is the lowest performer, ranking in the 9th percentile with a 0-star rating and only 5.45% proficiency in 7th-grade Math. The Alief ISD schools, including Holub Middle, Klentzman Intermediate, and Mata Intermediate, all rank in the bottom 26% of Texas middle schools.
A key takeaway is that charter schools dramatically outperform traditional public schools despite similar poverty levels. The Alief ISD schools show a pattern where only a small group of advanced students takes Algebra I, while the charter schools achieve high proficiency across all math levels. Strong reading scores at KIPP and Harmony appear to support overall academic success. The Alief ISD intermediate school model (grades 5-6) suggests academic challenges begin early, as students entering 7th grade at Olle and Holub are already behind state averages. Per-student spending is similar across all schools, ranging from $10,035 to $10,894, indicating the performance gap is not due to funding differences.
Thank you for your feedback!