Summary:
This analysis examines five elementary-level schools in Dallas, Texas, zip code 75203, serving grades Pre-Kindergarten through 8th grade, an area characterized by high economic disadvantage where all schools report a free/reduced lunch rate above 84%.
Two schools stand out for exceptional performance despite high poverty levels. James Bowie Elementary is the clear academic leader, ranking in the 84th percentile statewide with a 4-star rating, achieving test scores significantly above district and state averages—for example, 92.31% proficiency in 5th Grade Reading versus 58.47% statewide—despite 95.9% of students being economically disadvantaged. Felix G Botello Personalized Learning Elementary is a strong and consistent performer, ranking in the 70th percentile (3-star) with impressive 5th-grade scores, including 79.22% proficiency in Mathematics, far exceeding the state average of 47.38%. In contrast, Trinity Basin Preparatory - Dallas is the lowest-performing school, ranking in the 11th percentile (1-star), though it shows an "Algebra I Anomaly" where 95.45% of its 8th graders taking the Algebra I EOC exam were proficient, nearly double the state average. Cedar Crest Elementary has the highest economic disadvantage rate at 99.78%, while N W Harllee Early Childhood Center serves only PK-2nd grade with the lowest student-teacher ratio (10:1) and highest per-student spending ($15,943).
Key metrics show enrollment ranges from 148 students at N W Harllee to 1,873 at Trinity Basin, with an average free/reduced lunch rate of 91.2% across schools. Per-student spending varies from $9,426 at Trinity Basin to $15,943 at N W Harllee, but spending alone does not predict success—the highest-spending schools do not have the highest outcomes. Student-teacher ratios are generally low, from 10:1 to 16.4:1. A notable finding is that bilingual education appears to be a strength, particularly at James Bowie, where students taking Spanish-language STAAR tests often outperform state averages for Spanish test-takers. Additionally, several schools show inconsistent performance across grade levels, such as Cedar Crest where 3rd-grade Reading proficiency dropped from 74.19% to 35.48% in 4th grade, suggesting areas for district-level investigation within the Dallas Independent School District (Isd) and Trinity Basin Preparatory.
Thank you for your feedback!