Summary:
This analysis examines two middle schools in zip code 75090 (Sherman, TX), Sherman Middle and Piner Middle, both part of the Sherman Independent School District (ISD), which serves grades 6-8 and faces significant challenges as a district ranked in the 17th percentile statewide.
Piner Middle is the standout school in this area, showing a strong upward trajectory. It jumped from the 33rd percentile to the 49th percentile in state rankings over two years, earning a 2-star rating, while Sherman Middle has remained stagnant in the 25th-28th percentile range with a 1-star rating. Piner outperforms Sherman in nearly every subject, with the largest gaps in 6th Grade Reading (53.3% vs. 32.36%) and 6th Grade Math (43.94% vs. 24.18%). Both schools excel in Algebra I, with Piner achieving 100% proficiency and Sherman at 94.34%, far exceeding the district average of 40.99% and state average of 54.03%. However, this success does not translate to general 8th-grade math, where both schools fall well below the state average of 47.24%.
Key metrics reveal different challenges. Sherman Middle has a higher percentage of economically disadvantaged students (79.86% free/reduced lunch) compared to Piner Middle (67.99%), which likely contributes to the performance gap. Both schools struggle significantly in 8th Grade Science and Social Studies, with neither reaching 37% proficiency in Science and both below 21% in Social Studies—a critical weakness for the entire district. Piner also has a lower dropout rate (0.5% vs. 0.9%) and a slightly smaller enrollment (831 vs. 869). The district faces the key question of whether Piner's successful strategies can be replicated at Sherman, or if Sherman's higher concentration of poverty requires a fundamentally different approach.
Thank you for your feedback!