Summary:
This analysis examines four elementary schools in zip code 75048 (Sachse, TX), serving grades PK-5 across two districts: Wylie Independent School District (Isd) and Garland Independent School District (Isd).
The most significant finding is the stark performance gap between the two Wylie ISD schools and the two Garland ISD schools. Don Whitt Elementary is the standout performer, ranked 56th out of 4,627 Texas elementary schools (99th percentile) with a 5-star rating, achieving 88.39% proficiency in both 4th Grade Reading and Math. Cheri Cox Elementary is also a strong contender, ranked 173rd (96th percentile) with 86.57% proficiency in 4th Grade Math. In contrast, John W Armstrong Elementary (Garland ISD) ranks 503rd (89th percentile, 4-star), while Robert B Sewell Elementary (Garland ISD) ranks 1,893rd (59th percentile, 3-star), with only 27.52% of 4th graders proficient in Math. The Wylie ISD schools also have smaller student-teacher ratios (13.7-14.2) and higher spending per student ($11,304-$11,417) compared to Garland ISD schools (ratios of 17.2-17.7, spending $8,842-$9,261).
Key takeaways for parents: The district choice is the dominant factor, with Wylie ISD schools outperforming Garland ISD schools by a wide margin. A concerning "middle school drop" in Math is visible at Armstrong, where 5th Grade Math proficiency (53.28%) is far below 4th Grade (81.58%). However, a bright spot exists at Sewell, where 5th Grade Science (43.86% proficient) significantly exceeded district and state averages. Overall, families prioritizing top-tier performance should focus on the Wylie ISD schools, while those in the Garland ISD area may want to investigate specific grade-level strengths and weaknesses.
Thank you for your feedback!