Summary:
In zip code 75039 of Irving, Texas, there are two elementary schools serving grades K-5: La Villita Elementary and Uplift North Hills Prep Ps, which offer distinctly different educational experiences despite similar enrollment sizes.
Uplift North Hills Prep Ps is the standout school in this area, earning a 5-star rating and ranking in the 99th percentile statewide. It achieves exceptional academic results, with reading and math proficiency rates around 85%—far exceeding state averages of roughly 54% and 47%, respectively. This public charter school, part of the Uplift Education network, serves a student population with a low poverty rate (13.35% free/reduced lunch) and spends $10,428 per student. In contrast, La Villita Elementary is a solid 4-star traditional public school within the Carrollton-Farmers Branch Independent School District (Isd), ranking in the 82nd percentile. While it outperforms district and state averages, its proficiency rates (around 65% in reading and 59% in math) are significantly lower than Uplift's. Notably, Uplift achieves these results with a higher student-teacher ratio (19.7:1) compared to La Villita's 16.8:1, suggesting its success stems from factors like curriculum and school culture rather than class size alone.
A key takeaway is the stark contrast in science performance: Uplift's 5th graders achieve 64.22% proficiency in science, more than double the state average of 29.57% and well above La Villita's 46.38%. Additionally, Uplift shows remarkable year-over-year consistency, while La Villita experiences more fluctuation, particularly in math scores. It's also important to note that Uplift North Hills Prep Ps is a massive outlier within its own charter network, which ranks in the 30th percentile statewide, meaning this school's excellence is highly localized and not representative of Uplift Education as a whole.
Thank you for your feedback!