Summary
Villarreal Elementary in San Antonio, TX, serves 532 students in grades PK-5 as part of the Northside Independent School District (Isd), and while it offers a favorable student-to-teacher ratio of 11.5:1, it consistently ranks in the bottom 20% of Texas elementary schools, with a current 11th percentile ranking. The school serves a high-poverty community, with over 83% of students qualifying for free or reduced lunch, but its academic outcomes on STAAR exams are significantly below district and state averages, particularly in English-language Math and Science. For example, only about 24% of 3rd graders and 31% of 4th graders were proficient in Math, and 5th-grade Science proficiency has been alarmingly low, often in the single digits or low teens.
Interestingly, Villarreal shows a notable strength in its Spanish-language instruction, outperforming district and state averages in several areas, such as 3rd-grade Reading (34% proficient vs. 33% district) and 4th-grade Math (38% proficient vs. 28% district). This suggests the bilingual program is a relative asset. However, a critical concern is the sharp decline in performance for male students, who dropped from the 22nd percentile to the 9th percentile in recent years, making them the lowest-performing subgroup. On a positive note, 5th-grade Reading has shown a gradual upward trend, rising from 39% to 44% proficiency over four years, offering a potential model for improvement in other grades.
What makes Villarreal’s challenges particularly striking is the comparison to nearby schools serving similar demographics. Just 0.94 miles away, Esparza Elementary ranks in the 46th percentile with nearly identical poverty rates, achieving Reading proficiency rates nearly double Villarreal’s in 4th and 5th grades. Similarly, Idea Ingram Hills Academy, a charter school just 0.44 miles away with an even higher poverty rate, ranks in the 34th percentile and saw 75% of its 5th graders proficient in Reading compared to Villarreal’s 45%. These contrasts indicate that improvement is possible and likely tied to school-specific strategies, leadership, or culture, rather than socioeconomic factors alone.
Thank you for your feedback!