Summary
Idea Academy in Donna, TX, is a K-5 charter school serving 744 students, where over 97% qualify for free or reduced lunch, and it is part of the Idea Public Schools district. This school has experienced a sharp decline in performance, dropping from the 51st percentile statewide in 2022-2023 to the 22nd percentile in 2025-2026, a concerning trend that sets it apart from nearby traditional public schools. For example, Capt D Salinas II Elementary and Le Noir Elementary, both part of the Donna Independent School District (Isd), have shown significant improvement over the same period, with Le Noir achieving 86.57% proficiency in 4th-grade math compared to Idea Academy’s 36%.
Idea Academy struggles notably in math and science, with proficiency rates consistently below state averages and local peers. In 2025-2026, only 33% of 5th graders were proficient in math, while Capt D Salinas II Elementary reached 65%. Science scores are similarly weak, with just 26.72% of 5th graders proficient in 2024-2025. The school also operates with a high student-to-teacher ratio of 21.5:1, much higher than the nearby average of 15.7:1, which may limit individualized support for its high-needs population. While reading was once a relative strength, with scores exceeding state averages in 2023-2024, this advantage has faded, and all grade levels now fall below state benchmarks.
A critical concern is the school’s performance with special education students, which ranks in the 11th percentile and shows no signs of improvement. This is a major red flag for a school serving a highly disadvantaged community. Interestingly, Idea Academy previously excelled with "At Risk" students, ranking in the 79th percentile in 2018-2019, but this strength appears to have diminished. Overall, the school is being outperformed by local Donna ISD schools, which spend more per student (over $10,000 vs. Idea Academy’s $8,600-$9,000) and are showing stronger upward trends. Parents considering this school should weigh these factors carefully.
Thank you for your feedback!