Summary:
The Cleveland Independent School District (Isd) is home to two middle schools, Cleveland Middle and Santa Fe Middle, serving grades 6 through 8 in a community facing significant economic challenges, with over 91% of students across both schools eligible for free or reduced lunch.
When comparing the two schools, Cleveland Middle generally posts higher academic scores, consistently outperforming Santa Fe Middle in nearly every subject and grade level. For example, in the 2025-2026 school year, average reading proficiency at Cleveland Middle was 26.0% compared to 23.4% at Santa Fe Middle, and average math proficiency was 14.3% versus 9.3%. However, both schools rank in the bottom 5% of Texas middle schools, with Cleveland Middle in the 4th percentile and Santa Fe Middle in the 3rd percentile. A standout area for both is advanced math: over 70% of students taking the Algebra I End-of-Course exam at each school were proficient, far exceeding the state average of 54%. Santa Fe Middle has a slightly lower dropout rate (0.8%) than Cleveland Middle (1.0%), and its student-teacher ratio is a bit higher at 16.1:1 versus 15.3:1.
The most striking takeaway is the "Algebra I anomaly": while a small, select group of students excels in advanced math, the vast majority struggle with grade-level math and reading, with proficiency rates often half the state average or worse. This suggests the district effectively accelerates a few high-performing students but leaves many behind in foundational skills. Overall, the data paints a picture of schools under immense pressure from high poverty levels, yet they manage to retain students and offer a strong advanced math pathway for a fortunate few.
Thank you for your feedback!