Summary
West Elementary School is a PK–5 public school in McMinnville, Tennessee, serving 479 students as part of Warren County Schools. While the school holds a 1-star rating and ranks in the bottom quartile statewide (768th of 1,019 elementary schools for 2025–26), this is actually one of its best showings in a decade—up from the 13th percentile in 2023–24 to the 25th percentile now. The biggest bright spot is chronic absenteeism, which has dropped from 25.6% in 2022–23 to 15.9% in 2024–25, now below the state average. West also stands out for spending $15,028 per student, the highest among nearby Warren County schools, though that funding has not yet translated into top-tier academic results. Proficiency rates remain below state averages in all subjects, and the school trails several neighbors—for example, Bobby Ray Memorial School, less than a mile away, posts 43.2% math proficiency versus West’s 30.8%.
One of the most concerning patterns is a sharp academic drop between 4th and 5th grade. West’s 4th graders hit 50.0% proficiency in science, nearly matching the state average, but 5th graders collapse to just 15.9%—over 30 points below the state. Similar drops appear in math and ELA. Nearby Hickory Creek School has 5th-grade math at 50.5% and 5th-grade science at 39.8%, showing this cliff is not typical. On a more positive note, West is improving quickly across all subjects, gaining roughly 10 points in math and ELA and 12 points in science over two years. Subgroup results show particular progress for low-income, Hispanic, and special-education students, all of whom now rank better than the school’s overall percentile.
West remains a below-average school overall, but the trajectory is encouraging. It trails stronger neighborhood options like Centertown Elementary School and Eastside Elementary School, yet outperforms Morrison Elementary School and is similar to Dibrell Elementary School. The most urgent priority is understanding and fixing the 5th-grade experience, and the key question is whether West can sustain its gains, extend them upward, and convert its high spending into stronger outcomes for every grade level.
Thank you for your feedback!