Summary:
Agar-Blunt-Onida School District 58-3 has three small schools serving grades K–12: Onida Elementary - 04 (K–5, 79 students), Sully Buttes Middle School - 06 (6–8, 66 students), and Sully Buttes High School - 07 (9–12, 71 students). The most important finding is that Sully Buttes Middle is the district’s clearest academic standout, performing above the state in every reported middle-school grade and subject in 2025–26.
Sully Buttes Middle School - 06 also led Onida Elementary - 04 in all-grades results by 14 points in ELA (63% versus 49%) and 24 points in math (61% versus 37%). Middle-school grade 8 results were especially strong: ELA was 75%, 23 points above the state, math was 70%, 27 points above, and science was 65%, 25 points above. Elementary results were more uneven: fifth-grade math was 24%, 19 points below the state, while fifth-grade science was 59%, 17 points above. Sully Buttes High School - 07 had mixed 2025–26 ACT results: ELA was 30%, 18 points below the state; math was 35%, 1 point above; and science was 40%, 5 points below.
Elementary and middle all-grades scores fell from 2024–25 to 2025–26, and middle’s state advantage narrowed: its lead went from 17 to 14 points in ELA and from 21 to 17 points in math. SchoolDigger’s statewide percentile ranking rose for middle, from 72 to 90 over three years, but fell for elementary, from 66 to 36; high school’s ranking moved from 50 to 25 in the same period. In 2024–25, student-teacher ratios were 6.8 at elementary, 9.0 at middle, and 9.5 at high. Free/reduced lunch eligible shares that year were 27%, 29%, and 17%, respectively; these are context, not explanations for achievement. The high school’s earlier Smarter Balanced scores and latest ACT scores are not a like-for-like trend.
Thank you for your feedback!