Summary:
ZIP code 44865 covers the Plymouth-Shiloh area of Ohio, where three public schools serve students from preschool through 12th grade in the Plymouth-Shiloh Local district: Shiloh Elementary School (PK–4, 288 students), Shiloh Middle School (5–8, 205 students), and Plymouth High School (9–12, 118 students), together enrolling 611 students.
Shiloh Elementary is the strongest of the three by state rank, at the 63rd percentile with 3 stars and the lowest chronic absenteeism at 7.1%. It beats the state in all four reported 2025–2026 tests, including 4th grade math at 85.7% versus 67.3% statewide, though 3rd grade math fell sharply from 79.5% to 62.3%. Shiloh Middle (51st percentile, 3 stars) is the most uneven: 5th grade science and ELA both reached 97.7%, far above the state, while 7th grade math is just 31.8% and 7th grade ELA 49.0%, both below state. Plymouth High (43rd percentile, 2 stars) posts a 95.3% graduation rate and strong Biology results (86.4% vs. 67.0%), but Algebra I (46.5% vs. 61.6%) and Geometry (35.6% vs. 43.3%) lag the state.
District-wide, Plymouth-Shiloh Local ranks 394 of 773 — the 49th percentile with 2 stars — which masks the fact that the elementary and middle schools each earned 3 stars. Attendance separates the levels: elementary absenteeism (7.1%) is better than the district's 10.6%, while middle (13.6%) and high school (13.2%) are worse. Plymouth High reports the highest free/reduced lunch rate (97.46%) and the most per-student spending ($11,763 versus $9,910 at the elementary), yet the lowest rank, so resources alone don't explain the differences; the middle school's lunch rate is not reported. Enrollment also drops from 205 in grades 5–8 to 118 in grades 9–12, and year-over-year swings are large at both the middle and high school.
Thank you for your feedback!