Summary:
Plymouth-Shiloh Local is a small Ohio district with three schools — Shiloh Elementary School (PK–4), Shiloh Middle School (5–8), and Plymouth High School (9–12) — serving about 611 students, and it ranks at the 49th percentile statewide with 2 stars overall.
Shiloh Elementary School is the district's strongest performer: 3 stars, the 63rd percentile, and above the state in every reported 2025–26 test, including 4th grade math at 85.7% proficient versus 67.3% statewide. It also has the lowest chronic absenteeism at 7.1%, compared with the district's 10.6% — and it does this despite the lowest per-student spending ($9,910 in 2018–19) and the highest student/teacher ratio (13.7) of the three schools. Shiloh Middle School also earns 3 stars but is far less even: 5th grade reached 97.7% proficient in both science and ELA (versus 62.7% and 70.4% statewide), while 7th grade math was only 31.8% and 7th grade ELA 49.0%, both below state. Its absenteeism, 13.6%, is the highest in the district. The middle school's free/reduced lunch figure is not reported, so its poverty picture is unknown.
Plymouth High School is the smallest school (118 students) and has the lowest latest rank, the 43rd percentile with 2 stars. It shines in science and completion — Biology at 86.4% proficient versus 67.0% state and a 95.3% graduation rate, despite 97.46% free/reduced lunch — but lags in math, with Algebra I at 46.5% and Geometry at 35.6%, both below state. Middle and high absenteeism sit near 13%, double the elementary rate, and math is the district's most consistent weakness. Because the secondary schools are small, year-to-year swings in percentages should be read cautiously rather than as clear improvement or decline.
Thank you for your feedback!