Summary:
Hamilton City has two middle schools serving grades 7–8: Garfield Middle School (814 students) and Wilson Middle School (587 students), together enrolling 1,401 students in the Hamilton City district, which ranks 570 of 773 Ohio districts at the 26th percentile with 1 star.
Wilson has historically been the stronger of the two. In 2024–25 it ranked 463 of 1,036 (55th percentile, 3 stars) and scored above the state in Science 8 (66.2 vs 63), Mathematics 8 (59.4 vs 47.6), ELA 8 (55.5 vs 54.4), and Algebra I (100 vs 59.4). But in 2025–26 Wilson fell to 641 of 1,046 (39th percentile, 2 stars), with Science 8 dropping to 51.5 and Mathematics 7 to 25.0. Garfield has been steadier, holding 2 stars and reaching the 37th percentile in 2025–26, and it improved in Mathematics 8 (38.3 to 48.7), ELA 7 (51.6 to 54.7), and ELA 8 (38.6 to 46.6). In 2025–26 the schools traded strengths: Garfield led in Science 8, Mathematics 7, and ELA 7, while Wilson led in Mathematics 8, ELA 8, and Algebra I.
Algebra I is the standout for both: in 2025–26 Garfield scored 97.7 and Wilson 100, against district 65.6 and state 61.6 — though that End-of-Course exam likely reflects a select group of students rather than the whole school. Both schools lag well behind the state in 7th-grade math (Garfield 30.6 and Wilson 25.0 vs state 48.6), a district-wide weakness. Chronic absenteeism is high: 31.4% at Garfield and 33.6% at Wilson versus 31.1% districtwide. Wilson spends more per student ($6,104 vs $5,556, 2018–19 data) but has a higher student-teacher ratio (19.5 vs 15.0).
Thank you for your feedback!