Summary:
Zip code 12117 has two schools in Mayfield Central School District, serving pre-K through grade 12: Mayfield Elementary School enrolls 430 students, and Mayfield Junior/Senior High School enrolls 379, for 809 students combined. The clearest overall takeaway is that results vary substantially by subject and grade: elementary math is a strength, while elementary English language arts (ELA) and the junior/senior high school’s grade 7–8 results are below state averages.
Mayfield Elementary stands out in 2025–2026 math and fifth-grade science: math averaged 65% across grades 3–6, versus 56% statewide, and science was 58%, versus 45%. Its ELA average was lower than the state’s, at 41% versus 46%. At Mayfield Junior/Senior High, nine of ten reported Regents subjects were above state results; the average advantage across those subjects was 14 points. Algebra I was 92% versus 60%, while Living Environment was a notable exception at 22% versus 44%. In grades 7–8, the school was below the state in both ELA (49% versus 52%) and math (46% versus 52%).
Recent trends differ by school and subject. At Mayfield Elementary, the math advantage over the state grew from 5 points in 2024–2025 to 8 points in 2025–2026, while its ELA gap shifted from 4 points below the state to 5 points below. At Mayfield Junior/Senior High, the grade 7–8 math gap moved from 11 points above the state to 6 points below. SchoolDigger’s percentile ranking rose from 73 to 88 over the three reported years, even as those latest middle-grade comparisons weakened; the elementary school’s ranking went from 51 to 55. For context, in 2024–2025, student–teacher ratios were 10.8 and 10.3, respectively, and free/reduced lunch eligible shares were 33% and 29%. The high school’s graduation rate was 90% versus 83% statewide, while chronic absenteeism was 33% versus 31%.
Thank you for your feedback!