Summary
Melrose High is a small public high school in Melrose, NM, serving 79 students in grades 9–12 as part of Melrose Public Schools in a rural area about 15 miles from Floyd High. Because it is small, one class can cause large swings in test scores and rankings, and the state suppresses some values to protect student privacy. Melrose High has historically ranked well above the state median: it was 13th of 131 schools (90th percentile, 5 stars) in 2024–2025, but its latest 2025–2026 result is 49th of 132 (63rd percentile, 3 stars). That recent dip is noticeable, though earlier years often showed 4 or 5 stars.
Graduation outcomes are a clear strength. Melrose High’s 2023–2024 graduation rate was 91.8%, well above the state’s 78.0%. Floyd High’s most recent reported rate was 74.0% in 2022–2023, below the state that year, though the years do not align exactly. In 2025–2026, Melrose High’s 11th-grade language arts score was 45% versus the state’s 36.78%, and science was 40% versus 34.02%. Its SAT School Day English language arts score was 45% versus 37.07%. Math scores are suppressed for that year, so current math performance cannot be assessed. Floyd High reported 70% in 11th-grade science, compared with Melrose High’s 40%; both are above the state’s roughly 34%, but this is a small cohort and should be treated as a signal, not a definitive gap.
Melrose High’s free/reduced lunch rate jumped from about 24% in 2023–2024 to 98.73% in 2024–2025, which likely reflects a reporting or program change rather than a sudden demographic shift. Even so, its low-income subgroup ranked 7th of 115 schools statewide (94th percentile, 5 stars) in 2024–2025. Student-teacher ratios are harder to compare because Melrose High’s 2024–2025 value is missing; its 2023–2024 ratio was 14.9, while Floyd High reported 4.1 in 2024–2025, an unusually low figure. Overall, Melrose High has strong graduation and above-state English language arts and science results, but its latest ranking has softened and some current data are suppressed. Compared with Floyd High, Melrose High has stronger historical rankings and graduation evidence; Floyd High’s clearest recent advantage is 11th-grade science.
Thank you for your feedback!