Summary:
Newcomb, New Mexico is a small, rural community in San Juan County served by four schools spanning the full PK–12 pipeline — two elementary, one middle, and one high school — with no alternative campuses — enrolling about 620 students in total. Three of the four, Newcomb High, Newcomb Elementary, and Newcomb Middle, belong to Central Consolidated Schools, a district ranked in the bottom tenth of New Mexico. Tohaali' Community School is its own district and serves grades K–8.
Comparing the campuses, Newcomb Elementary is the clear academic standout: 2 stars and the 33rd percentile statewide, with all-grades proficiency of 30.69% in Language Arts and 21.78% in Math — both above the district average, which is unusual for a school in this district. Newcomb Middle ranks in the 16th percentile with 1 star; its 8th grade science (27.03%) beats the district, but its all-grades math of 8.97% is less than half the district rate. Newcomb High ranks in the 6th percentile with 0 stars and reports every test measure as under 20%, yet graduates 87.4% of students — above both district (82.2%) and state (80.6%).
A few things stand out for families. Poverty is essentially universal here — every school reports 97–100% free or reduced lunch — so it does not distinguish one campus from another. Math, not reading, is the shared weak point, most severely at the middle level. Tohaali' Community School has no test scores or state ranking reported, so 101 students cannot be compared academically. Class sizes vary widely, from 7.7 students per teacher at the elementary to 16.8 at Tohaali'. With no alternative school in the community, students who struggle in the traditional setting have limited local options.
Thank you for your feedback!