Summary:
ZIP code 07670 has six schools in the Tenafly Public School District: four elementary schools, one middle school and one high school, serving 3,404 students from elementary through high school. The elementary schools’ average across matched 2025–2026 tests was 75%, compared with 45% for the state, a 30-point lead; all four were above state results in the comparisons provided. The most important takeaway is that local elementary results are consistently strong relative to the state, though schools differ from one another.
Walter Stillman School stands out among the elementary schools: it led five of seven grade-and-subject comparisons and had the highest seven-test average, 82%, versus 71% at Ralph S Maugham School, an 11-point difference. J Spencer Smith School averaged 76%, and Malcolm S Mackay School averaged 72%. Maugham had the lowest result in three tests, while Mackay had the lowest in three others. At the secondary level, Tenafly Middle School had 100% proficiency in grade 7 Algebra I and grade 8 Geometry; Tenafly High School had a 96% graduation rate and 3% chronic absenteeism, compared with 89% and 14% statewide.
Elementary results dipped overall from the previous year: the average fell 3 points, from 78% to 75%. The pattern varied by school: Smith rose 2 points, while Maugham fell 7, Mackay fell 5 and Stillman fell 1. SchoolDigger gives five stars to five schools and four to Maugham; its latest percentile rankings range from 89 at Maugham to 98 at Stillman. Student-teacher ratios range from 11.1 to 13.0. The free/reduced lunch eligible measure for 2024–2025 ranges from 1% at Mackay to 5% at Tenafly Middle; these figures are context, not explanations for test results.
Thank you for your feedback!