Beta You're viewing our redesigned school list. Prefer the classic layout?

Tenafly Public School District


At a glance
31stof 607 New Jersey districts▲ 6
Better than 94% of New Jersey districts
500 Tenafly Road
Tenafly, NJ 07670-1796
·(201) 816-4500·All New Jersey district rankings →
Statewide performance 2018–2026
2026: better than 94.9% of districts
6
Schools
3,404
Students
5
5-star schools
Top rankedWalter Stillman School29th of 1,331 New Jersey elementary schools
▲
Biggest riser
J Spencer Smith School up 32 spots statewide this year
◉
Smallest classes
Tenafly High School 11.1 students per teacher
SchoolDigger ratings
5★
4★
Summary:

Tenafly Public School District serves 3,404 students across six schools, from four elementary schools through one middle school and one high school. The latest test results cover 2025–2026, and the clearest overall strength is that every reported, nonsuppressed score is above its corresponding state result: elementary averages are 77% in ELA, 78% in math and 60% in grade 5 science, compared with state averages of 49%, 47% and 27%.

Walter Stillman School is the most consistently strong elementary school, leading five of seven grade-and-subject comparisons; its seven-score average is 82%, compared with 76% at J Spencer Smith School, 72% at Malcolm S Mackay School and 71% at Ralph S Maugham School. Stillman is not always on top: Smith leads grade 5 math at 89% versus Stillman’s 80%, while Maugham leads grade 4 math at 88%. Maugham and Mackay are near the bottom in several other comparisons, but Mackay is second in grade 5 science. The middle and high schools also exceed state results by wide margins: Tenafly Middle School scores 57% in grade 8 math versus 23% statewide, and Tenafly High School scores 92% in grade 9 Geometry versus 50% statewide.

Elementary results have softened overall, though trends differ by school: the average across matched scores fell 3 percentage points from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, including an 11-point drop in grade 5 science. Maugham’s seven-score average fell 7 points and Mackay’s fell 5, while Smith rose 2 and Stillman slipped 1. SchoolDigger ranks the district 31st of 607, with five stars; its latest school rankings place Stillman 29th of 1,331 elementary schools, Tenafly High 28th of 434 high schools and Tenafly Middle 30th of 743 middle schools. As context, all six schools report free/reduced lunch eligible figures for 2024–2025; elementary shares range from 1% at Mackay to 3% at Stillman and 4% at Maugham. Stillman and Mackay have similar student-teacher ratios of 11.1 and 11.8, while Maugham’s is 13.0; these figures describe school context, not what explains test results.

Ranking:
Map legend
E Elementary M Middle H High A Alternative P Private




Districts nearby

SchoolDigger data sources: National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Department of Education, the U.S. Census Bureau and the New Jersey Department of Education.

IMPORTANT DISCLAIMERS: Not all boundaries are included. We make every effort to ensure that boundaries are up-to-date. But it's important to note that these are approximations and are for general informational purposes only. To verify legal descriptions of boundaries or school locations, contact your local tax assessor's office and/or school district.

Diagnostics